Efficiency of Combined Co-composting, Vermicomposting, and Drying in the Treatment of Cadmium, Mercury, Helminths, and Coliforms in Sludge from Wastewater Facilities for Potential Agricultural Applications
Maria Aileen Leah G. Guzman1*, May Ann A. Udtojan1, Marylle F. Del Castillo1,
Emilyn Q. Espiritu1, Jude Anthony N. Estiva2, Jewel Racquel S. Unson1,
Joan Ruby E. Dumo1, and Jay Roy E. Espinas1
1Department of Environmental Science, Ateneo de Manila University,
Loyola Heights 1108 Quezon City, Philippines
2Aparri Engineering LLC, 131 Main St., Suite 180, Hackensack NJ 07601 USA
Sludge generated from wastewater treatment facilities has been applied in agriculture as soil conditioners. However, the incomplete and/or inappropriate treatment of wastewater may result in sludge that may still contain heavy metals, helminth ova, and coliforms posing a risk to both humans and the environment. This study assessed various pretreatment techniques such as co-composting, vermicomposting, and a combination of these on sludge samples to remove heavy metals (cadmium and mercury), helminth ova, and coliforms. Physico-chemical and biological analyses were used to compare untreated (i.e. raw) and treated sludge samples. The results showed that for the raw sludge, mercury (4.02 +/– 0.17 mg/kg) and cadmium (6.30 +/– 0.48 mg/kg) exceeded the limits specified under the Philippine National Standard (PNS) for Organic Soil Amendments of 2 mg/kg and 5 mg/kg, respectively. Laboratory examinations also revealed the presence of helminth ova (5 ova/g) and coliforms (10 CFU/g) in the samples. Sludge samples subjected to a combination of co-composting and vermicomposting resulted in the elimination of mercury and a significant reduction in cadmium concentration from 6.30 mg/kg to 1.12 mg/kg. No helminth ova were observed in the samples after further drying. However, both treated and untreated sludge samples had low nutrient content. The study highlights the need for raising public awareness and educating farmers on the potential risks associated with the use of raw sludge for agriculture.
The management of sludge produced from wastewater treatment facilities is one of the most expensive challenges faced by the wastewater industry that engineers and regulators are trying to solve (Metcalf and Eddy 2003; Sinha et al. 2009). The production of massive quantities of sludge has led to the development of various disposal methods including the use of landfills, incinerators, and land application. Among these, the use of sludge for land application is proposed to be the most resourceful and economical alternative method for disposal. Sludge is a potential source of nutrients that can be used as a soil conditioner or fertilizer (Stadelmann et al. 2001; Metcalf and Eddy 2003). Several studies have shown that sludge contains compounds that provide a rich source of organic matter, nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium, and other plant nutrients that may be of agricultural value (EC 2001; Usman et al. 2012). The high organic matter in sludge can improve the physical characteristics of soils such as its structure, water retention, and porosity (Hossain et al. 2017). Hence, it is environmentally friendly and also an economically efficient method of solid waste disposal. . . . read more
ALIDADI H, PARVARESH AR, SHAHMANSOURI MR, POURMOGHADAS H, NAJAFPOOR AA. 2007. Combined compost and vermicomposting process in the treatment and bioconversion of sludge. Pak J Biol Sci 10(21): 3944–3947.
BAZRAFSHAN E, ZAZOULI MA, BAZRAFSHAN J, BANPEI AM. 2006. Co-composting of Dewatered Sewage Sludge with Sawdust. Pak J Biol Sci 9(8): 1580–1583.
[BWD] Baliuag Water District. 2012. Septage Collection Scheme. Retrieved on 22 Apr 2017 from http://baliwagwd.com/contents/septage-collection-scheme/
CAPPON CJ. 1981. Mercury and Selenium Content and Chemical Form in Vegetable Crops Grown on Sludge-Amended Soil. Arch. Environ. Contam Toxicol 10: 673–689.
[CEPMO] Baguio City Environment and Parks Management Office. 2014. A Situationer: Wastewater Management in the City of Baguio. Retrieved on 24 Apr 2017 from http://www.unescap.org/sites/default/files/10-Waste%20water%20management% 20in%20the%20city%20of%20Baguio,%2 0Philippines%20.pdf
COFIE O, KONĔ D, ROTHENBERGER S, MOSER D, ZUBRUEGG C. 2009. Co-composting of faecal sludge and organic solid waste for agriculture: process dynamics. Water Res 43(18): 4665–4675.
COGGER CG, SULLIVAN DM, HENRY CL, DORSEY KP. 2000. Biosolids Management Guidelines for Washington State. Washington State Department of Ecology.
[DENR] Department of Environment and Natural Resources. 2004. DENR Administrative Order 36, Series of 2004: Revised Procedural Manual on Hazardous Waste Management.
DOMINGUEZ J, EDWARDS CA. 2004. Vermicomposting organic wastes: a review. In: Soil Zoology for Sustainable Development in the 21st Century. Hanna SH, Mikhail WZ ed. Cairo: Safwat H Shakir Hanna. p. 369–395.
DURUIBE JO, OGWUEGBU MO, EGWURUGWU JN. 2007. Heavy Metal Pollution and Human Biotoxic Effects. Int J Phys Sci 2(5): 112–118.
EASTMAN BR, KANE PN, EDWARDS CA, TRYTEK L, GUNADI B, STERMER AL, MOBLEY JR. 2001. The effectiveness of vermiculture in human pathogen reduction for USEPA biosolids stabilization. Compost Sci Util 9(1): 38–41.
[EC] European Commission. 2001. Disposal and recycling routes for sewage sludge Part 3. Retrieved on 22 Jul 2016 from http://ec.europa.eu/environment/archives/waste/sludge/pdf/ sludge _ disposal3.pdf
FORNES F, MENDOZA-HERNANDES D, GARCIA DE LA FUENTE R, ABAD M, BELDA RM. 2012. Composting versus Vermicomposting: A Comparative Study of Organic Matter Evolution Through Straight and Combined Processes. Bioresour Technol 118: 296–305.
GRAFT O. 1982. Vergleich der Regenswurmaten Eisenia foetida und Eudrilus eugeniae hinsichlich ihrer Eignung zur Proteinwinnung aus Abfallstoffen. Pedobiologia 23: 277–282.
GUPTA R, GARG VK. 2008. Stabilization of Primary Sewage Sludge During Vermicomposting. J Hazard Mater 153(3): 1023–1030.
HOCK LS, BAHARUDDIN AS, AHMAD MN, SHAH UKM, RAHMAN NAA, ABD-AZIZ S, HASSAN MA, SHIRAI Y. 2009. Physicochemical Changes in Windrow Co-Composting Process of Oil Palm Mesocarp Fiber and Palm Oil Mill Effluent Anaerobic Sludge. Aust J Basic & Appl Sci 3(3): 2809–2816.
HOSSAIN MZ, FRAGSTEIN PV, NIEMSDORFF PV, HESS J. 2017. Effect of Different Organic Wastes on Soil Properties and Plant Growth and Yield: A Review. Sci Agric Bohem 48(4): 224–237.
IWAI CB, TA-OUN M, CHUASAYATEE T, BOONYOTHA P. 2013. Management of Municipal Sewage Sludge by Vermicomposting Technology: Converting a Waste into a Bio Fertilizer for Agriculture. Int J Environ Rural Dev 4(1): 169–174.
JENKINS J. 1999. The Humanure Handbook. A Guide to Composting Human Manure, Second Edition. Grove City, PA: Joseph Jenkins, Inc. Retrieved from https://humanurehandbook.com/downloads/H2.pdf
[JICA] Japan International Cooperation Agency. 1991. Basic Design Study Report on the Baguio Septage System Rehabilitation Project in the Republic of the Philippines [Supplementary Study].
KAVIRAJ S, SHARMA S. 2003. Municipal Solid Waste Management Through Vermicomposting Employing Exotic and Local Species of Earthworms. Bioresour Technol 90(2): 169–173.
LESMANA SO, FEBRIANA N, SOETAREDJO FE, SUNARSO J, ISMADJI S. 2009. Studies on Potential Applications of Biomass for the Separation of Heavy Metals from Water and Wastewater. Biochem Eng J 44: 19–41.
MANGUIAT IJ. 1997. Sewage sludge: turning an environmental pollutant into an agricultural resource. Retrieved on 28 Oct 2019 from http://agris.fao.org/agris-search/search.do?recordID=PH1998010123
METCALF AND EDDY, INC. 2003. Wastewater Engineering: Treatment, Disposal and Reuse, 4th ed. New York: McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Ltd.
MOODLEY P, ARCHER C, HAWKSWORTH D, LEIBACH L. 2008. Standard Methods for the Recovery and Enumeration of Helminth Ova in Wastewater, Sludge, Compost and Urine-Diversion Waste in South Africa. Pretoria, South Africa: Water Research Commission.
NAIR J, SEKIOZIOC V, ANDA M. 2006. Effect of Pre-Composting on Vermicomposting of Kitchen Waste. Bioresource Technology 97: 2091–2095.
NDEGWA PM, THOMPSON SA. 2000. Effects of C-to-N Ratio on Vermicomposting of Biosolids. Bioresour Technol 75: 7–12.
NDEGWA PM, THOMPSON SA. 2001. Integrating Composting and Vermicomposting in the Treatment and Bioconversion of Biosolids. Bioresour Technol 76: 107–112.
[PNS] Philippine National Standards, [BAFS] Bureau of Agriculture and Fisheries Standards. 2016. PNS/BAFS 183:2016: Organic Soil Amendments.
REINECKE AJ, VILJOEN SA, SAAYMAN RJ. 1992. The Suitability of Eudrilus eugeniae, Perionyx excavatus and Eisenia fetida (Oligochaeta) for Vermicomposting in Southern Africa in Terms of Their Temperature Requirement. Soil Biol Biochem 24(12): 1295–1307.
ROBINSON A. 2003. Urban sewarage and sanitation: lesson learned from case studies in the Philippines. World Bank Water and Sanitation Program – East Asia and the Pacific.
SCHONNING C, STENSTROM TA. 2004. Guidelines for the Safe Use of Urine and Faeces in Ecological Sanitation. Sweden: Ecosanres, SEI.
SINGH J, KALAMDHAD AS. 2011. Effects of Heavy Metals on Soil, Plants, Human Health and Aquatic Life. Int J Res Chem Environ 1(2): 15–21.
SINHA RK, HEART S, BHARAMBE G, BHARAMBHATT A. 2009. Vermistabilization of Sewage Sludge (BIosolids) by Earthworms: Converting a Potential Biohazard Destined for Landfill Disposal into a Pathogen-free, Nutritive and Safe Biofertilizer for Farms. Waste Manag Res 28(10): 872–881.
SOOBHANY N, MOHEE R, GARG VK. 2015. Comparative Assessment of Heavy Metal Content During the Composting and Vermicomposting of Municipal Solid Waste Employing Eudrilus eugeniae. Waste Manage 39: 130–145.
STADELMANN FX, KULLING D, HERTER U. 2001. Sewage Sludge: Fertilizer or Waste? Retrieved on 24 Apr 2017 from http://library.eawag.ch/EAWAGPublications/openaccess/ Without_EAWAG_number/eawagnews/www_en53/en53e_printer/en53e_stadelm_p.pdf
SUTHAR S, SINGH S. 2008. Feasibility of Vermicomposting in Biostabilization of Sludge from a Distillery Industry. Sci Total Environ 394: 237–243.
SUTHAR S, SAJWAN P, KUMAR K. 2014. Vermiremediation of Heavy Metals in Wastewater Sludge from Paper and Pulp Industry Using Earthworm Eisenia Fetida. Ecotox Enviro Safe 109: 177–184.
TRIPATHI G, BHARDWAJ P. 2004. Decompostion of Kitchen Waste Amended with Cow Manure Using an Epigeic Species (Eisenia fetida) and an Anecic Species (Lampito mauritti). Bioresour Technol 92(2): 215–218.
[USEPA] United States Environmental Protection Agency. 1989. Publicly Owned Water Treatment Works Sludge Sampling and Analysis Guidance Document. Retrieved from http://greencriminology.org/glossary/publicly-owned-water-treatment-works-powts-us/ on 08 May 2019.
[USEPA] United States Environmental Protection Agency. 1993. Methods for Microbiological Analyses of Sewage Sludge. Washington, DC: Dynamic Corporation.
[USEPA] United States Environmental Protection Agency. 1994. Biosolids Management Handbook EPA Region VIII. Retrieved on 24 Apr 2017 from https://www.epa.gov/sites/production/ files/documents/handbook1.pdf
[USEPA] United States Environmental Protection Agency. 2000. Biosolids Technology Fact Sheet. Land Application of Biosolids. Washington, DC: Environmental Protection Agency.
[USEPA] United States Environmental Protection Agency. 2003. Control of Pathogens and Vector Attraction in Sewage Sludge. Cincinnati, OH: US Environmental Protection Agency.
USMAN K, KHAN S, GHULAM S, KHEN MU, KHAN N. 2012. Sewage Sludge: An Important Biological Resource for Sustainable Agriculture and Its Environmental Implications. Am J Plant Sci 3: 1708–1721.
VERMICO. 2013. Journal Publishes Study of Worms Reducing Human Pathogens in Biosolids. Retrieved on 17 Jan 2017 from http://www.vermico.com/journal-publishes-study-of-worms-reducing-humanpathogens-in-biosolids/
[WHO] World Health Organization. 1989. Health Guidelines for the Use of Wastewater in Agriculture and Aquaculture [Technical Report Series 778]. Geneva.